It is imperative for you to pick suitable tires for your car. The quality of your car’s tires can be a deciding factor in life and death situations. You have to consider tires based on its traction and grip on all kinds of surface. You also need to consider how durable they are.
You have to put the ability of tires to handle season changes into consideration. The situation of the road surface will be different, depending on whether it is summer, rainy or snowy. Choosing all-season tire can be tricky but you can always pick BFGoodrich Advantage T/A and Michelin Defender.
The BF Goodrich Advantage T/A is grand touring tire which can handle all kinds of weather including light snow. This tire is designed to have sporty looks while still being suitable for everyday use since it has excellent traction in all seasons. It is suitable for sedans and sporty coupes.
Its competitor, the Michelin Defender, is also an excellent all weather tire. It is a standard touring tires which is suitable for family cars, minivans and small crossover vehicles. This tire is good for lower speed vehicles and it can make you stay comfortable while riding.
Both tires are considered to have good performance for most cars, but which one is the best?
BFGoodrich Advantage T/A Key Features Overview
BFGoodrich Advantage T/A put emphasize on longer tread wear and driving comfort while still able to handle all kind of season without sacrificing tread design attractiveness.
The Advantage T/A has a symmetric non-directional tread pattern. The tread is reinforced by silica compound which is capable to prolong the wear time. You will be offered with better steering response and stability. The robust shoulder block enhances the tire’s lateral strength and better cornering.
For wet surface, this tire is equipped with g-Grip so that your tire won’t easily slip and improve the handling. The risk of hydroplaning is minimalized thanks to the wide circumferential grooves. Over all, the Advantage T/A has excellent wet grip.
In terms of structural integrity, the Advantage T/A is quite outstanding due to the twin steel belts which are wrapped by Equal Tension Containment System. The g-Wedge sidewall stabilizer also enhances the tire durability for higher speed driving without sacrificing comfort.
Michelin Defender Key Features Overview
Michelin Defender is a standard all-season tire which is good for all type of weather. It is suitable for family sedans, minivans and crossovers. This tire will keep you safe on the road by utilizing the Michelin’s unique technology.
The traction of this tire is enhanced by silica tread compound, just like the one in Advantage T/A. Michelin Defender is also utilize the IntelliSipe technology which will provide more grip and traction on wet or snowy surfaces. It also proves better brake performance and handling.
The Green X technology which is also utilized by this tire provides a special interlocking action which provides more rigidness toward the tread block. It also provides you with lower rolling resistance for better fuel economy.
The Michelin Defender is equipped with four circumferential grooves and a lot of lateral grooves that provides better grip and reduced risk of hydroplaning when it is raining. As a result, this tire offers you with excellent handling and traction on wet surface which increase the safety.
In terms of structural integrity, this tire is equipped with two steel belts inside it and a polyester cord body which reinforced by MaxTouch Construction. The way this tire is engineered provides you with excellent strength and durability. It is an all-rounder tire which is excellent in all type of situations.
BFGoodrich Advantage T/A vs Michelin Defender Head to Head Battle
In terms of traction, both tires seem to show excellent capability to some extent. The Advantage T/A provides you with an above average performance on dry surface. On wet surface, the traction and the handling is also excellent. See also: BF Goodrich KO vs KO2.
The Michelin Defender also provides you with good traction quality in all weather. The handling is also very good since it is crisp and responsive.
Michelin Defender will provide you with comfort and quieter tire noise. The BFGoodrich Advantage T/A on the other hand, will start to get louder as it ages. The road noise will become less subtle as the tire wears.
The tread life in BFGoodrich Advantage T/A is reported to be better than the Michelin Defender. The tread guarantee for Michelin Defender is 90,000 miles but many users use the guarantee few miles before 90k, which shows the lack of tread life performance.
The cornering grip in Michelin Defender also needs improvement. At higher speeds, this tire provides less cornering grip. Despite that, it is still an above average all-season tire.
The prices of both tires are quite similar. You can acquire a Michelin Defender tire for $85 and up depending on the size and store. The BFGoodrich Advantage T/A is slightly pricier. You can get it for $88 and up depending on the size and store.
For tread life warranty, BFGoodrich Advantage T/A offers you with 6 year or 60,000 miles for H and V speed rated tires. For T speed rated tire, you will be offered with 75,000 miles warranty. The mileage warranty will be halved for the rear tires if the size is different from the front tires.
The Michelin Defender offers you with longer 6 years mileage warranty. For T and H speed rated tires, you will get a whopping 90,000 miles. For the V rated speed, the warranty is 80,000 miles.
Just like the Advantage T/A, the mileage is halved for the rear tires if it has different size from the front tires.
BF Goodrich Advantage T/A vs Michelin Defender
|BF Goodrich Advantage T/A||Michelin Defender|
|- The ride on these tires is very smooth and quiet at relatively lower speeds.||- Featuring bright white or blue Permanent Raised Rubber Tire Stickers pre-installed on the top and bottom of each tire|
|- Traction on wet roads is very good. Good resistance to hydroplaning as well.||- Guaranteed New - Never been mounted - Ready to mount and drive|
|- Better handling in light snow than Michelin MXV4's according to one reviewer.||- Tire Lettering will match existing black mold letters, as pictured (Can vary but roughly ~0.75") Contact us to customize/change lettering size or colors|
The BFGoodrich Advantage T/A will give you a good all weather tire which will last longer than the Michelin defender. The only downside is the noise but it is still manageable. Overall this tire gives you a good value for your money. The Michelin defender, despite its shortcomings, is still a good all weather tire. It also provides you with longer warranty and there has been some upgraded version, such as the Defender T + H, which overcomes the weakness.